Plaintiff, the defendant as a pretext for canceling administrative act is untenable.

In the fine collection of storage, the decision as reward awarded the plaintiff $ 1 whole tax administration reward.

June 3, State Tax Xigong told Renle Liang, for his reported cases, the IRD has made administrative punishment decision, and a written notice to the Inland Revenue Department to receive his award one yuan entire report.

About the plaintiff that the defendant committed a minimum of $ 10 question Report Award, because of the commitment is the defendant's higher administrative department of Luoyang City, State Revenue on September 25, 2006 for the conduct of the "ordinary invoices never want activity" and set up, and

However, if a little empathy can go, it is also very easy to perceive that not only did not reflect the slightest "to encourage the reporting of" good effect, and have actually become very "hinder Report" alternative ridicule.

According to the State Administration of Taxation Xigong relevant personnel, first of this bulletin for the range of only ten kinds of invoices, and a statute of limitations, the ten kinds invoice has been replaced by the new version of the invoice; secondly, Luoyang City, State Revenue prevailing departmental rules and

The defendant decided to award legal procedures Xigong State Revenue believe that their reward for Renle Liang's legal procedures.

Report on the unit after the punishment accordingly and in accordance with relevant procedures carried out on Ren Leliang award, in accordance with the relevant provisions, according to the collection of taxes (fines) to 100 yuan, 5,000 yuan reward given to the provisions of this ratio with reference to,

there will be "encouraged a" good attitude do

According to relevant regulations, Xigong State Tax incentives for whistleblowers Renle Liang conducted, and the legal procedures, there are no procedural violations.

The court dismissed the plaintiff legally unreasonable Xigong People's Court after hearing that the defendant as the tax authorities, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the tax law cases with prosecutors rewarded in accordance with the relevant provisions of the statutory duties.

State Revenue Xigong day propaganda Report prizes, retaining tax glorious Renyue Liang felt he did not experience the glory, but felt by the fooled.

bonus, the highest bonus per case not more than 100,000 yuan, minimum award amount is $ 10, Ren Leliang that Xigong State Revenue for him to make administrative decisions Award of $ 1, there is no legal basis and factual basis and violate

its external public commitment.

But the court also held that stands to reason that the tax authorities should consider, where appropriate whistleblower award for the implementation of actions arising from the necessity of reporting expenditures encouragement whistleblower protection tax initiative.

Luoyang City, the IRS was September 25, 2006 to the public commitment, invoice violations reported and verified according to the law, according to the whistleblower's contribution, according to the actual amount of the tax recovered within 10 percent of master meter

¡õ East this report trainee reporter Oscillation / Ventura plaintiff winning one yuan men reported feeling humiliated indicted on May 11 this year, the Ren Leliang Xigong, CyberMart in Luoyang city to buy computer chair, when he request an invoice when buying stuff

According to the case report timeliness, prosecution material to provide clues and evidence informative level,ray ban pas cher, content and verified the contents of the report precisely the extent and amount of the tax collection storage, in accordance with the prosecutor on the case taking into account the following criteria bonuses: "storage amount of the tax collection

Later, he received State Revenue Xigong a Speedpost, enclosing an award notice: Due Renyue Liang meritorious, the IRS decided to make a dollar grand prize, but also with limited effective ninety days

They confiscated a computer city fine of 100 yuan, the State Tax Bureau Xigong exercised in accordance with the corresponding proportion of discretion given to Ren Leliang 1 yuan reward.

To report this case, Ren Leliang round dozen times,hollister france, the light car will cost 50 yuan,gucci outlet, not including lost income, and risked more than thirty degrees Celsius, State Tax Xigong his reward only be able to buy

hardly willing to respond positively, enthusiastically bullied.

In the meantime, Ren Leliang with State Revenue Xigong provide relevant evidence, but also on the illegal merchants to testify, and later Ren Leliang report the facts established.

For Renle Liang mentioned in the complaint, "Luoyang City, State Revenue was September 25, 2006 public commitment to the community", there are "minimum award amount is $ 10" content.

State Administration of Taxation of the documents have been invalid, so Ren Leliang basis can not be established.

May 18, Ren Leliang Computer City, this behavior will be reported to the State Administration of Taxation Xigong.

As the informants said,louboutin, he took a taxi to the Inland Revenue Department report, costs are more than a dollar back and forth, some cost money to worry about "positive response", the return was actually such a dumbfounding "Report Award", you

There are time constraints, the event has ended.

100 million or less, to give 5,000 yuan bonus; report violations of the tax treatment is not verified amount of tax payable, in accordance with the amount of fines collected warehousing Article 6 in accordance with the provisions of this standard be issued with bonus "provisions

Whistleblowers who report violations of the tax cap only award criteria, there is no minimum requirement, the law gives the right to the tax authorities discretion discretion.

Defendant in this case $ 1 bonus reward plaintiff Report whole,mulberry outlet, though legal, but the amount is low, there is the obvious problem of rationality.

Ren Leliang baffled after receiving the report, he did not know the Inland Revenue Department notice this award is to encourage reporting behavior or suppress his enthusiasm informers.

document collection, fails to receive, as a waiver.

However, the combination of all factors into consideration, in order to promote everyone to protect tax law enforcement, are a good thing to do good deeds, to form a good social habits.

bottles of mineral water,toms shoes.

, but was refused, saying that if you want to still have to pay 20 yuan invoice invoice money.

Case, the plaintiff Renyue Liang in the shopping, the merchant refused to invoicing, the plaintiff in order to report the merchant's tax violations, the defendant verified after the merchant impose administrative penalty of $ 100.

To dignity, Ren Leliang appeal to the People's Court of Luoyang Xigong, pleading the court shall revoke State Revenue Xigong award decision to come back to reward him.

award criteria.

Cheng Yong said that incentives should be considered to compensate for the loss factor,louboutin pas cher, giving whistleblowers a spiritual solace, positive publicity in order to play a guiding role.

User "chenyfly": Before people heard "prize to encourage the public to report illegal tax," the publicity, there may be believed, and even move their heart, then, witnessed this embarrassing one dollar "Report Award", I am afraid

Xigong State Revenue, said the officer, upon receipt of Renyue Liang's report, they promptly in accordance with the statutory procedures for processing.

Renle Liang pleaded that he would file an appeal.

Eventually, Xigong People's Court sentenced Renyue Liang lost the first trial, rejected the claim, litigation costs 50 yuan by the plaintiff Renyue Liang commitment.

This decision is consistent with State Administration of Taxation, Ministry of Finance promulgated the "Report illegal Taxpayer Award Interim Measures," the relevant provisions of Article VI.

Lawyers award compensation factors should also be taken into account 21 evening,hollister, Henan, director of law firm lawyers through the East Wing into the East this reporter in an interview that a dollar is a reward.

User legal but unreasonable friends "midline sniper": this matter, from the legal point of view, award $ 1, compliance with the law, but from the perspective of rationality, unfair.